Object's details: ‘SHALL’ AMBIGUITIES IN EU LEGISLATIVE TEXTS

Provider:Platforma Otwartych Czasopism Naukowych UAM

Description

Title:
‘SHALL’ AMBIGUITIES IN EU LEGISLATIVE TEXTS
Creator:
FELICI, Annarita
Description:
This paper investigates the modal ‘shall’, whose excessive use can be problematic both in legal translation and interpretation (Coode 1843, Driedger 1976). The context of analysis is the EU for offering a relative young legal environment where translation represents the main channel of communication. The analysis moves from the deontic speech acts of ordering and prohibiting and looks at examples of performativity where ‘shall’ is not only deontically binding, but it is also used to express a necessary condition or to set a new state of things up. The disambiguation is particularly evident in multilingual translation and is performed with the help of parallel concordances, which also shed light on the conceptual framework of norms. Data consist of a parallel corpus including English, French, German and Italian versions of EU legislative texts chosen between 2001-04. As a term of comparison, a small comparable corpus containing English orginal texts has also been compiled.;
Autorka analizuje użycie czasownika modalnego ‘shall’, którego nadużywanie może prowadzić do problemów translacyjnych i interpretacyjnych (Coode 1843, Driedger 1976). Korpus badawczy obejmował akty normatywne Unii Europejskiej w języku angielskim, francuskim, niemieckim i włoskim wydawane w okresie od 2001 do 2004 roku. Należy tu zaznaczyć, że komunikacja prawnicza w ramach tej organizacji międzynarodowej ma stosunkowo krótką tradycję, a przekład prawniczy jest głównym kanałem komunikacyjnym. Analiza wykazała, że czasownik modalny ‘shall’ jest używany do wyrażania zarówno nakazu, zakazu jak i opisu stanów faktycznych.
Object availability:
free access
Rights:
Prawa autorskie (c) 2018 Annarita FELICI
Date:
2012.01.15
Type:
info:eu-repo/semantics/article;
info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion;
Peer-reviewed Article
Language:
English;
eng
Source:
Comparative Legilinguistics; Vol. 10 (2012); 51-66;
Comparative Legilinguistics; Tom 10 (2012); 51-66;
2391-4491;
2080-5926
Format:
application/pdf
Publisher:
Adam Mickiewicz University Poznan
Relation: http://pressto.amu.edu.pl/index.php/cl/article/view/6924/6932
Subject:
shall;
czasownik modalny;
tłumaczenie prawnicze;
komunikacja prawnicza;
nakaz;
zakaz;
legal translation;
legal communication;
modal verbs;
deontic speech
Identifier: http://pressto.amu.edu.pl/index.php/cl/article/view/6924
Data provider:
Platforma Otwartych Czasopism Naukowych UAM

Similar objects

‘SHALL’ AMBIGUITIES IN EU LEGISLATIVE TEXTS

Creator:FELICI, Annarita

Date:2012.01.15

Type:text

THE PARAMETERS OF MULTILINGUAL LEGAL COMMUNICATION IN A GLOBALIZED WORLD

Creator:SANDRINI, Peter

Date:2009.07.04

Type:text

A HANDFUL OF REMARKS ON THE NECESSITY FOR COMMUNICATION OPTIMIZATION BETWEEN SWORN TRANSLATORS AND LAW ENFORCEMENT BODIES, FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF STRATEGIES FOR ITS ACHIEVEMENT AND POTENTIAL BENEFITS

Creator:ZIELIŃSKI, Lech

Date:2016.06.02

Type:text

LEXICAL PITFALLS IN POLISH-ENGLISH LEGAL TRANSLATION: A CASE STUDY INVOLVING STUDENTS OF ENGLISH PHILOLOGY IN POLAND

Creator:ZYGMUNT, Łukasz

Date:2012.04.15

Type:text

MACHINE TRANSLATION – CAN IT ASSIST IN PROFESSIONAL TRANSLATION OF CONTRACTS?

Creator:SYCZ-OPOŃ, Joanna

Date:2016.11.05

Type:text

ZUR VERSTÄNDLICHKEIT VON ÜBERSETZUNGEN DEUTSCHER UND POLNISCHER GERICHTSBENENNUNGEN

Creator:BIELAWSKI, Paweł

Date:2019.01.04

Type:text

CAPITALISING ON TRANSLATION MARKET DATA IN THE FIELD OF COMMERCIAL LAW

Creator:WIĘCŁAWSKA, Edyta

Date:2019.05.15

Type:text

THE TEXTUAL ROLE OF REPETITION IN THE TRANSLATION OF POLISH AND HUNGARIAN LEGAL TEXTS

Creator:KACZMAREK, Karolina

Date:2009.07.04

Type:text

Federacja Bibliotek Cyfrowych

Object's details: ‘SHALL’ AMBIGUITIES IN EU LEGISLATIVE TEXTS

Description

Similar objects