Object's details: Adequacy of legal instruments for shaping the agricultural regime

Provider:Platforma Otwartych Czasopism Naukowych UAM

Description

Title:
Adequacy of legal instruments for shaping the agricultural regime
Creator:
Truszkiewicz, Zygmunt
Description:
The Act of 2003 on shaping the agricultural system was adopted following the concerns about potential acquisition of agricultural land by citizens from EU Member States. The same fears determined the tightening of restrictions on the ownership of agricultural land adopted in 2016. However, the effectiveness of these restrictions – from the point of view of the objectives articulated much more widely in the Act can hardly be noticed. The basic objective, which was to improve the area structure of agricultural holdings, has not really been achieved since during the 15 years of the operation of the Act, the State purchased only about 20 thousand hectares of agricultural land pursuant to its provisions. Further, the requirement underlying another objective of the Act (i.e. ensuring that agricultural activity is carried out in agricultural holdings by persons with appropriate qualifications) seems unreasonable in contemporary social and economic conditions and, what is more, it violates fundamental freedoms protected by the Constitution. Realistically, the Act has successfully albeit only partially achieved its third basic objective, which was to counteract excessive concentration of agricultural land, limiting the acquisition of agricultural land of an area exceeding 300 ha.;
La legge del 2003 sul regime agricolo è stata approvata come risposta al timore di vedere gli stranieri provenienti dall’UE acquistare terreni agricoli. Le stesse paure hanno determinato l’inasprimento delle restrizioni alla compravendita di terreni agricoli nel 2016. Tuttavia, la loro efficacia – dal punto di vista degli obiettivi articolati molto più ampiamente nella legge menzionata – è insignificante. È difficile parlare del conseguimento dell’obiettivo di base, cioè quello di ampliare la superficie delle aziende agricole, poiché nell’arco di 15 anni a partire dalla sua entrata in vigore, lo Stato polacco, su scala nazionale, ha acquisito – richiamandosi alla legge in esame – soltanto circa 20 000 ettari di fondi agricoli. In più, il requisito di possedere qualifiche agricole, correlato con un altro fine prefissato nella legge (ovvero assicurare, nelle aziende agricole, lo svolgimento di attività agricola da parte di persone con qualifiche appropriate) dovrebbe essere considerato, nelle odierne condizioni socio-economiche, irrazionale e allo stesso tempo come un requisito che viola le libertà fondamentali tutelate dalla Costituzione. In termini concreti, la legge menzionata consente comunque di impedire un’eccessiva concentrazione di fondi agricoli, vietandone l’acquisizione oltre i 300 ettari, sebbene non nella misura massima.;
Ustawę z 2003 r. o kształtowaniu ustroju rolnego przyjęto ze względu na obawy przed nabywaniem gruntów rolnych przez cudzoziemców z UE. Te same obawy przesądziły o zaostrzeniu ograniczeń w obrocie własnościowym gruntami rolnymi w 2016 r. Jednakże efektywność tych ograniczeń – z punktu widzenia celów o wiele szerzej wyartykułowanych w ustawie – jest znikoma. Trudno bowiem mówić o realizowaniu podstawowego celu, jakim jest poprawianie struktury obszarowej gospodarstw rolnych, skoro w okresie 15 lat działania ustawy państwo nabyło w skali kraju – na jej podstawie – tylko ok. 20 tys. ha gruntów rolnych. Powiązany z kolejnym celem ustawy (tj. zapewnieniem prowadzenia działalności rolniczej w gospodarstwach rolnych przez osoby o odpowiednich kwalifikacjach) wymóg posiadania kwalifikacji rolniczych należy zaś uważać, we współczesnych uwarunkowaniach społeczno-gospodarczych, za nieracjonalny, a jednocześnie naruszający podstawowe wolności chronione konstytucyjnie. Ustawa umożliwia realizowanie trzeciego podstawowego celu, jakim jest przeciwdziałanie nadmiernej koncentracji nieruchomości rolnych, ograniczając nabywanie nieruchomości rolnych ponad 300 ha, aczkolwiek nie w pełnym zakresie.
Object availability:
free access
Date:
2020.06.29
Type:
info:eu-repo/semantics/article;
info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion;
Artykuł naukowy
Language:
Polish;
pol
Source:
Przegląd Prawa Rolnego; No. 2(25) (2019); 69-89;
Przegląd Prawa Rolnego; Nr 2(25) (2019); 69-89;
2719-7026;
1897-7626
Format:
application/pdf
Publisher:
Adam Mickiewicz University Poznan
Relation: http://pressto.amu.edu.pl/index.php/ppr/article/view/23360/21957
Subject:
obrót nieruchomościami rolnymi;
ustawa o kształtowaniu ustroju rolnego;
ocena realizacji celów tej ustawy;
trading in agricultural property;
Act on shaping the agricultural system;
evaluation of implementation of objectives of the Act;
compravendita di fondi agricoli;
legge sul regime agricolo;
valutazione del proseguimento dei fini contenuti nella legge in oggetto
Identifier: http://pressto.amu.edu.pl/index.php/ppr/article/view/23360
Data provider:
Platforma Otwartych Czasopism Naukowych UAM

Similar objects

Adequacy of legal instruments for shaping the agricultural regime

Creator:Truszkiewicz, Zygmunt

Date:2020.06.29

Type:other

Acquisition by foreigners of shares in companies owning agricultural real estate

Creator:Łobos-Kotowska, Dorota

Date:2018.06.01

Type:text

Protection of agricultural property in the light of the act on shaping the agricultural system

Creator:Litwiniuk, Przemysław

Date:2020.06.29

Type:text

Conversion of a company and the act on shaping the agricultural system

Creator:Bieluk, Jerzy

Date:2020.06.29

Type:text

Concept of agricultural property, an agricultural holding and agricultural activity in the act on shaping the agricultural system – selected issues from notarial practice

Creator:Suchoń, Aneta

Date:2020.06.29

Type:text

Trading in agricultural property in the light of the freedom of movement of capital – from the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union

Creator:Włodarczyk, Beata

Date:2020.06.29

Type:text

The construction of a family farm in the context of the construction of an agricultural holding as provided for in the civil code and in the Act on shaping the agricultural system

Creator:Gała, Paweł | Łobos-Kotowska, Dorota | Stańko, Marek

Date:2021.12.30

Type:text

Ewolucja ustawodawstwa w obrocie ziemią rolniczą z zasobu Skarbu Państwa i między osobami fizycznymi

Creator:Karwat-Woźniak, Bożena | Sikorska, Alina | Buks, Bogdan

Date:2017.12.31 | 2017

Type:image

Federacja Bibliotek Cyfrowych

Object's details: Adequacy of legal instruments for shaping the agricultural regime

Description

Similar objects